Excommunication and Shunning
To understand Jesus' words in Matthew 1815-17 you have to understand the world that he lived in. The first century Mediterranean culture was centered on
community and driven by an honor/shame code of ethics. When there was division
in the community it threatened the well-being of the entire community and
brought shame upon it. That’s why eventually Jesus advises getting the
community involved in personal issues of sin.
The other cultural trait that comes into play with these
verses is that of the honor/shame basis for community. People have written
dissertations on this subject. All of first century Greco-Roman life was built
on the idea of honor and shame. In a nutshell it goes like this – when you did
things that the community considered good, you brought honor to the community
and you were rewarded by the community. When you did something that the
community considered bad or offensive, you brought shame upon the community and
you were punished by the community. The
punishment – public chastisement, public announcement of your betrayal against
the community, exclusion from certain community events or leadership positions
– in worse case scenarios it could include public whipping or beating (see
Paul), shunning, excommunication – and in the most extreme cases, capital
punishment by stoning. All of these "shaming" punishments were enacted as an attempt to maintain control and order in the community. The goal was conformity to community moral/ethical standards, and the restoration of those who erred.
This idea of honor/shame was powerful because it permeated
everything. Those who brought honor to the community were treated almost like
gods. Those who brought shame were rejected.
Most people living in the honor/shame culture would rather commit suicide
than shame the community. It was that powerful.
The other thing you have to understand is that in the first
century world a person depended on their community for survival. You could not survive long outside the community. Literally, physically – you could not survive.
There were no grocery stores. No restaurants. No homeless shelters.
Anthropologists estimate an average 2 year life expectancy for those who were,
for whatever reasons, abandoned by their community. So excommunication from the
community was a death sentence. It was reserved for only the worse
offenses.
That is no longer true today. If a person is shunned by one church community, they can simply walk across the street to another church community and be welcomed and helped. If their family disowns them, they can simply live apart from the family and can easily survive without family.
In fact, the disciplinary method of "shunning" or "excommunication" actually has the opposite effect today -- not only does it NOT bring reconciliation to the person, it causes the community to outsource its problems to some other community. There is no real "working at it" in order to bring reconciliation. It's too simple to just walk away and go to some other community.
A better and more biblical approach is to keep the person in the community and allow the community to continue to speak into their lives. If the person continues to sin, their sins will catch up to them (that's the tough love part) and the community will be their to help them pick up the pieces.
For more on the Honor/Shame culture of the first century see:
Honor, Patronage, Kinship & Purity: Unlocking New Testament Culture by David deSilva
Honor and Shame in the Gospel of Matthew by Jerome H. Neyrey
St. Paul Returns the to the Movies: Triumph Over Shame by Robert Jewett
Power and Privilege: A Theory of Social Stratification by Gerhard E. Lenski
Tools for Dealing with Anger
(for more on these click HERE)
Relaxation
Simple relaxation tools, such as deep breathing and relaxing
imagery, can help calm down angry feelings.
Cognitive
Restructuring
Simply put, this means changing the way you think. Angry
people tend to curse, swear, or speak in highly colorful terms that reflect
their inner thoughts. When you're angry, your thinking can get very exaggerated
and overly dramatic. Try replacing these thoughts with more rational ones. For
instance, instead of telling yourself, "oh, it's awful, it's terrible,
everything's ruined," tell yourself, "it's frustrating, and it's
understandable that I'm upset about it, but it's not the end of the world and
getting angry is not going to fix it anyhow."
Be careful of words like "never" or
"always" when talking about yourself or someone else. "This
!&*%@ machine never works," or "you're always forgetting
things" are not just inaccurate, they also serve to make you feel that
your anger is justified and that there's no way to solve the problem. They also
alienate and humiliate people who might otherwise be willing to work with you
on a solution.
Problem Solving
Sometimes, our anger and frustration are caused by very real
and inescapable problems in our lives. Not all anger is misplaced, and often
it's a healthy, natural response to these difficulties. There is also a
cultural belief that every problem has a solution, and it adds to our
frustration to find out that this isn't always the case. The best attitude to
bring to such a situation, then, is not to focus on finding the solution, but
rather on how you handle and face the problem.
Better Communication
Angry people tend to jump to—and act on—conclusions, and
some of those conclusions can be very inaccurate. The first thing to do if
you're in a heated discussion is slow down and think through your responses.
Don't say the first thing that comes into your head, but slow down and think
carefully about what you want to say. At the same time, listen carefully to
what the other person is saying and take your time before answering.
It's natural to get defensive when you're criticized, but
don't fight back. Instead, listen to what's underlying the words: the message
that this person might feel neglected and unloved. It may take a lot of patient
questioning on your part, and it may require some breathing space, but don't
let your anger—or a partner's—let a discussion spin out of control. Keeping
your cool can keep the situation from becoming a disastrous one.
Using Humor
"Silly humor" can help defuse rage in a number of
ways. For one thing, it can help you get a more balanced perspective. This will
take a lot of the edge off your fury; and humor can always be relied on to help
unknot a tense situation.
The underlying message of highly angry people, Dr. Deffenbacher
says, is "things oughta go my way!" Angry people tend to feel that
they are morally right, that any blocking or changing of their plans is an
unbearable indignity and that they should NOT have to suffer this way. Maybe
other people do, but not them!
There are two cautions in using humor. First, don't try to
just "laugh off" your problems; rather, use humor to help yourself
face them more constructively. Second, don't give in to harsh, sarcastic humor;
that's just another form of unhealthy anger expression.
What these techniques have in common is a refusal to take
yourself too seriously. Anger is a serious emotion, but it's often accompanied
by ideas that, if examined, can make you laugh.
Changing Your
Environment
Sometimes it's our immediate surroundings that give us cause
for irritation and fury. Problems and responsibilities can weigh on you and
make you feel angry at the "trap" you seem to have fallen into and
all the people and things that form that trap.
Give yourself a break. Make sure you have some
"personal time" scheduled for times of the day that you know are
particularly stressful. One example is the working mother who has a standing
rule that when she comes home from work, for the first 15 minutes "nobody
talks to Mom unless the house is on fire." After this brief quiet time,
she feels better prepared to handle demands from her kids without blowing up at
them.
More Anger Management Tips
(for more on these click HERE)
1. Think before you speak
In the heat of the moment, it's easy to say something you'll
later regret. Take a few moments to collect your thoughts before saying
anything — and allow others involved in the situation to do the same.
2. Once you're calm, express your anger
As soon as you're thinking clearly, express your frustration
in an assertive but nonconfrontational way. State your concerns and needs
clearly and directly, without hurting others or trying to control them.
3. Get some exercise
Physical activity can help reduce stress that can cause you
to become angry. If you feel your anger escalating, go for a brisk walk or run,
or spend some time doing other enjoyable physical activities.
4. Take a timeout
Timeouts aren't just for kids. Give yourself short breaks
during times of the day that tend to be stressful. A few moments of quiet time
might help you feel better prepared to handle what's ahead without getting
irritated or angry.
5. Identify possible solutions
Instead of focusing on what made you mad, work on resolving
the issue at hand. Does your child's messy room drive you crazy? Close the
door. Is your partner late for dinner every night? Schedule meals later in the
evening — or agree to eat on your own a few times a week. Remind yourself that
anger won't fix anything and might only make it worse.
6. Stick with 'I' statements
To avoid criticizing or placing blame — which might only
increase tension — use "I" statements to describe the problem. Be
respectful and specific. For example, say, "I'm upset that you left the
table without offering to help with the dishes," instead of, "You
never do any housework."
7. Don't hold a grudge
Forgiveness is a powerful tool. If you allow anger and other
negative feelings to crowd out positive feelings, you might find yourself
swallowed up by your own bitterness or sense of injustice. But if you can
forgive someone who angered you, you might both learn from the situation. It's
unrealistic to expect everyone to behave exactly as you want at all times.
8. Use humor to release tension
Lightening up can help diffuse tension. Use humor to help
you face what's making you angry and, possibly, any unrealistic expectations
you have for how things should go. Avoid sarcasm, though — it can hurt feelings
and make things worse.
9. Practice relaxation skills
When your temper flares, put relaxation skills to work.
Practice deep-breathing exercises, imagine a relaxing scene, or repeat a
calming word or phrase, such as, "Take it easy." You might also
listen to music, write in a journal or do a few yoga poses — whatever it takes
to encourage relaxation.
10. Know when to seek help
Learning to control anger is a challenge for everyone at
times. Consider seeking help for anger issues if your anger seems out of
control, causes you to do things you regret or hurts those around you.
Very nice and interesting blog, thanks for this post...it's been great reading this.
ReplyDelete